
The Perfect Potato Salad
Everyone has their own idea of the perfect potato salad. My favorite is Lulu’s Potato Salad.
For me, texture and flavor determines the most delicious potato salads. I’ve tasted some good ones made with mayo or even Miracle Whip. Some versions include sugar, mustard and/or eggs. I’m not a big fan of extra sugar or eggs.
Call me Goldilocks, but the perfect potato salad has to be a little bit creamy, but still have some texture. It has to have some diced vegetables that aren’t too big. The dressing has to have some tanginess with a little bit of sweetness but not too much. The color has to be the right shade of yellow, but not so much that it screams MUSTARD! I also like a little bit of fresh green color and flavor mixed in, meaning chopped fresh parsley and fresh dill, when I have it on hand. And, sorry to disappoint, NO EGGS or Miracle Whip!

Leaving Home Cookbook to the rescue
Believe it or not, meeting my standards wasn’t as hard as it seemed thanks to an old trusty cookbook from my collection–Leaving Home.
My perfect potato salad is a recipe I’ve used for decades. It’s based on a recipe from Lulu Grace’s Leaving Home cookbook that dates back many years now. The book was graciously gifted to me by Lulu via her stepdaughter, who was my neighbor when I lived in Texas. You can tell by looking at my battered and beaten copy that I’ve used Lulu’s recipes many times. I like the book so much that I even wrote an entire blog post about it.
There’s nothing special in the book’s appearance, with it’s plastic comb binding and lack of photos (most books at the time didn’t include photos), but every recipe I’ve tried over the years has been easy to prepare and delicious. Sadly the book is out of print, so if you happen to find one at a garage sale or thrift shop, grab it.
What Makes Lulu’s Potato Salad so special
The secret to this potato salad recipe is using a combination of boiled potatoes with canned white potatoes, with a dressing made using mayo and pickle relish.
The dressing is mayo based (I used Hellman’s), with dill pickle relish for a slight pickle flavor and tang. I prefer sweet pickle relish, which she gives as an option.
This salad has the right amount of yellow color and mustard flavor, with the recipe calling for Grey Poupon Dijon mustard. I use regular yellow mustard or stone ground mustard when I don’t have Dijon on hand and the salad is still delicious. You’re looking for a slightly yellow color not an overpowering yellow.
Unlike Lulu, who uses dry parsley flakes, I use fresh chopped Italian parsley and/or fresh dill. If I don’t have fresh dill, I will add some dried dill, about 1 teaspoon. Celery and onion are also added. For my own version, I also add some diced sweet yellow pepper only because I’m not a fan of green pepper and I like sweet pepper in my potato salad.
Canned Potatoes?
That’s right–canned white potatoes! Lulu says you can use either freshly boiled potatoes or the canned version. When I first made the salad, I missed the either/or part and used half fresh and half canned. The salad turned out perfect. It had the perfect texture–creamy but not smooth. I’ve been using that combination ever since.
Dice the canned potatoes and add them to the bowl of diced boiled potatoes (I use red or Yukon gold). Grab a potato masher and mash about half of the potatoes in the bowl.
Note: If you can’t find canned potatoes or would rather not using a canned version, dice some of the fresh potatoes larger than most of the potatoes. These will be very slightly “under cooked”compared to most of the potatoes and will add texture.

What’s in Lulu’s Potato Salad
- potatoes (I like red or Yukon gold/yellow potatoes)
- caned white potatoes
- mayonnaise (I like Hellman’s)
- sweet pickle relish (or dill pickle relish)
- Dijon mustard
- fresh Italian parsley
- fresh dill (optional)
- seasoned salt
- celery stalk
- small onion
- sweet yellow pepper
How to make the Salad
- In a large pot, bring cups of water to a boil
- Add 1 pound of uncooked potatoes.
- Boil for 10 minutes until a paring knife can be inserted into a potato and removed without resistance.
- Drain the potatoes and let them cool slightly.
- While potatoes are cooking, combine the mayo, pickle relish, mustard, parsley, and dill in a small bowl.
- Place the cooled potatoes in a large bowl.
- Season the potatoes with seasoned salt.
- Mash some of the chunks of potatoes so salad will be creamy but not smooth.
- Add the diced onion, celery, and yellow pepper (if using).
- Stir the mayonnaise mixture into the the bowl of potatoes.
- Mix well. Cover and chill until until cold.
Other Favorite Classic Salads
Creamy Macaroni Salad Retro Style
LuLu’s Potato Salad
Ingredients
- 1 pound potatoes peeled, diced and cooked
- 1 15- ounce can white potatoes diced
- 3/4 cup mayonnaise
- 1/8-1/4 cup sweet pickle relish or dill pickle relish
- 2 teaspoons Dijon mustard
- 2 teaspoons chopped fresh parsley
- 1 teaspoon chopped fresh dill optional
- 1 teaspoon seasoned salt
- 1 celery stalk diced
- 1/2 small onion diced
- 1/2 sweet yellow pepper diced (optional)
Instructions
- In a large pot, BRING 6 cups of water to a boil and ADD the 1 pound of uncooked potatoes.
- BOIL10 minutes until a paring knife can be inserted into a potato and removed without resistance.
- DRAIN and let COOL slightly.
- While potatoes are cooking, COMBINE mayo, pickle relish, mustard, parsley, and dill in a small bowl.
- PLACE cooled potatoes in a large bowl. SEASON with seasoned salt. MASH some of the chunks of potatoes so salad will be creamy but not smooth.
- ADD diced onion, celery, and yellow pepper (if using).
- STIR in mayonnaise mixture.
- MIX well. COVER and CHILL until cold.








You must be logged in to post a comment.